Guy’s Florida Keys Favorites
If you’re a fan of food exploration and have a penchant for unique dining experiences, then you’ve likely heard of the beloved television show “Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives.” Hosted by the charismatic Guy Fieri, the show takes viewers on a culinary journey across America, uncovering hidden gems and mouthwatering dishes along the way. And yes, the Florida Keys have had their fair share of delicious spotlights on this popular show!
Land2Shore LLC participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we may get paid commissions on editorially chosen products purchased through our links to retailer sites. Our editorial content is not influenced by any affiliate partnerships, and all opinions expressed here are our own. By purchasing through our affiliate link, you not only enhance your adventures but also support the creation of more content that celebrates the Florida Keys.
1 | Key Largo
The Fish House Restaurant and Seafood Market
Location: 102401 Overseas Highway, Key Largo, Florida
Website: The Fish House Restaurant and Seafood Market
Featured Dish: Fish Matecumbe, Smoked Fish Dip and Key Lime Pie
The Fish House is a local favorite known for its casual atmosphere and delectable seafood dishes. Season 24, Episode 4 (“Smoke and Seafood”) showcases their mouthwatering Fish Matecumbe, a perfect blend of fresh flavors and island vibes.
Recipe: Smoked Fish Dip (courtesy of The Fish House/Food Network)
Recipe: Fish Matecumbe (courtesy of The Fish House/Food Network)
DiGiorgio’s Cafe Largo
Location: 99530 Overseas Highway, Key Largo, Florida
Website: Digiorgio’s Cafe Largo | Cafe Largo Italian Restaurant
Featured Dish: Veal Chop Florentine and Truffled Lobster Mac & Cheese
DiGiorgio’s Cafe Largo offers a unique culinary experience with its creative menu and cozy ambiance. Featured in Season 24, Episode 5 (“International Appeal”), their Truffled Lobster Mac & Cheese steals the show with its decadent combination of Lobster and gooey cheese.
Recipe: Veal Chop Cutlet Florentine (courtesy of DiGiorgio’s Cafe/Food Network)
Recipe: Truffled Lobster Mac and Cheese (courtesy of DiGiorgio’s Cafe/Food Network)
Pilot House Restaurant & Marina
Location: 13 Seagate Boulevard, Key Largo, Florida
Website: Pilot House Marina
Featured Dish: Harvey’s Fish Sandwich
Pilot House Restaurant & Marina offers more than just great food; it provides stunning waterfront views and live entertainment. Featured in Season 24, Episode 7 (“Succulent Sandwiches”), their Harvey’s Fish Sandwich is a crowd-pleaser, showcasing the best of Keys comfort food.
Recipe: Pan-Seared Scallops over Lobster-Prosciutto Risotto (courtesy of Pilot House/Food Network)
.
2 | Islamorada
Green Turtle Inn
Location: 81219 Overseas Hwy (Mile Marker 81), Islamorada, Florida
Website: Green Turtle Inn Restaurant
Featured Dish: Turtle Chowder
Established in 1947, the Green Turtle Inn has a rich history and has been a beloved dining spot in Islamorada for decades. Featured in Season 24, Episode 6 (“Tacos, Turtles and Tri-Tip”), its cozy atmosphere and delectable seafood dishes make it a standout destination for visitors exploring the Keys.
Recipe: Meatloaf (courtesy of Green Turtle Inn/Food Network)
Islamorada Shrimp Shack
Location: 81901 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, Florida
Website: islamoradashrimpshack.com
Featured Dish: Shrimp Fritters and Senator-Style Hook and Cook
Shrimp Shack captures the essence of laid-back island living with its fresh seafood and casual ambiance. Featured in Season 24, Episode 4 (“Smoke and Seafood”), their Shrimp Fritters are a flavorful delight that showcases the best of Keys cuisine.
M.E.A.T. Eatery & Taproom
Location: 88005 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, Florida (MM88 -Oceanside)
Website: M.E.A.T. Eatery and Taproom
Featured Dish: Wings, Pork Rinds
M.E.A.T. Eatery & Taproom is more than just a restaurant; it’s a culinary journey that celebrates the art of food. In Season 24, Episode 8 (“Hot Meat and Cool Veg”), Guy Fieri sampled their House-Made Pork Rinds with chimichurri aioli dipping sauce and House Smoked Chicken Wings. Both mouthwatering creation that showcases the freshest ingredients and bold flavors of the Keys.
3 | Marathon
Herbie’s Bar & Chowder House
Location: 6350 Overseas Highway, Marathon, Florida
Website: Herbies Bar and Chowder House
Featured Dish: Chicken and Smashed Potato
Herbie’s Bar is more than just a place to grab a bite; it’s a local institution beloved for its laid-back atmosphere and mouthwatering seafood. In Season 34, Episode 6 (“Pasta, Potatoes and Pescatarian”), Guy Fieri sampled their iconic Chicken and Smashed Potato, a flavorful creation that perfectly captures the essence of the Keys.
Recipe: Chicken and Smashed Potato (courtesy of Herbie’s Bar & Chowder House/Food Network)
Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar
Location: 1406 Oceanview Avenue, Marathon, Florida (Oceanside)
Website: Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar
Featured Dish: Lobster Enchiladas and “King of the Jungle Roll” (Lionfish Sushi)
Castaway Restaurant & Bar offers a taste of the Caribbean in the heart of Marathon. Season 34, Episode 8 (“Taste of the Tropics”) showcases their mouthwatering Lobster Enchiladas and their famous “King of the Jungle Roll” (Lionfish Sushi), filled with flavorful ingredients that transport diners to the tropics. Make sure to take a peek into the canals surrounding the restaurant … manatees can often be seen playing there.
Irie Island Eats
Location: 4540 Overseas Highway, Marathon, Florida (Gulfside)
Website: Irie Island Eats
Featured Dish: Mojo Chicken and Mango Ribs
Push open the swinging doors and let the tropical garden lead you to this local’s favorite! Irie Island Eats brings a taste of Jamaica to the Florida Keys with its authentic Caribbean cuisine. Featured in Season 34, Episode 7 (“Pig’s Feet, Mojo and Chow-Chow”), their Mojo Chicken is a spicy and savory delight that ignites the senses.
Recipe: Pineapple Mojo Chicken Noodle Bowl (courtesy of Irie Island Eats/Food Network)
Sparky’s Landing
Location: 58900 Overseas Highway, Marathon, Florida
Website: Sparky’s Landing – Fish n Cocktails – Bar & Grill
Featured Dish: Fire & Ice Tuna
Sparky’s Landing captures the essence of island living with its waterfront location and laid-back atmosphere. Triple D Nation Season 1, Episode 26 (“From the Seas and Lots of Cheese”) introduces viewers to their tantalizing Fire & Ice Tuna, a crowd-pleasing favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Recipe: Fire & Ice Tuna (courtesy of Sparky’s Landing/Food Network)
4 | Key West
Garbo’s Grill
Location: 409 Caroline Street, Key West, Florida
Website: Garbo’s Grill
Featured Dish: Korean BBQ Tacos and Umamiburger
Garbo’s Grill is a hidden gem known for its inventive tacos and flavorful twists on classic dishes. Located on the same property as Hank’s Hair of the Dog Saloon, Garbo’s is a late night favorite for food truck tropical fusions. Featured in Season 19, Episode 6 (“Kickin’ It in Key West”) AND Season 0, Episode 30 (“Food Truckapalooza”), their Korean BBQ Tacos and Umamiburger are fusions of bold flavors that leave a lasting impression.
Recipe: Korean Bulgogi Taco (Courtesy of Food Network)
DJ’s Clam Shack
Location: 629 Duval Street, Key West, Florida
Featured Dish: Lobster Roll, Conch Fritters and Garlic Butter Clams
DJ’s Clam Shack is a cozy eatery in the heart of the Duval Street action, specializing in fresh seafood and classic New England fare. Featured in Season 0, Episode 38 (“Extra Helpings”) AND Season 19, Episode 6 (“Kickin’ It in Key West), their Lobster Roll is a buttery indulgence that captures the essence of coastal dining.
Recipe: New England Clam Chowder (Courtesy of Food Network)
The Florida Keys are not only a paradise for beach lovers and outdoor enthusiasts but also a culinary haven for foodies from around the world. Thanks to “Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives,” these hidden gems have been brought into the spotlight, allowing visitors to indulge in the diverse flavors and vibrant dining scene of the Keys. Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, mouthwatering sandwiches, or decadent desserts, the restaurants featured on the show offer something for every palate. So, next time you find yourself in the Florida Keys, be sure to embark on your own flavor-filled adventure and experience the magic of these beloved eateries firsthand.
